Why Showing Up Personally on Social Media (and Your Website) Matters for Local Businesses

Mary Jewett is a marketing consultant and speaker specializing in helping independent and family-owned businesses get more from their marketing and advertising efforts.

Hi, I'm mary

If you own a small, local business, you’ve probably heard the phrase “people buy from people.” It’s more than a catchy saying—it’s the reality of today’s marketing world. Your community doesn’t just want to know what you sell or what services you provide. They want to know who you are.

In an era where nearly every business has a social media page and a website, what sets you apart isn’t only your pricing or promotions. It’s your face, your story, and your personality.

People Connect With People, Not Logos

Think about your own habits: when scrolling on social media, which posts stop your thumb? A generic graphic with text? Or a photo of someone you know—or even someone who looks relatable?

The same is true for your customers. When they see you, your employees, your family, or your business in action, they’re more likely to pause, engage, and remember. Your logo is important for brand recognition, but it’s your people that build trust.

The Power of Personal Posts

  • Humanizes your business: Sharing your face, your story, and your journey makes your brand approachable and authentic.
  • Builds trust: Customers feel more confident supporting businesses where they know who’s behind the scenes.
  • Creates relatability: People want to work with businesses run by real humans who share their values and community ties.

Examples of what to share:

  • A quick video of you explaining why you started your business.
  • Behind-the-scenes moments—your team prepping for the day, your office dog, your tools or supplies.
  • Community involvement—volunteering, sponsoring a local event, or enjoying a night at a hometown restaurant.

Your Website Needs YOU Too

Social media is just the start. If your website only shows products, services, or stock images, you’re missing a chance to build a real connection. Adding professional photos of you and your team, along with an authentic “About Us” page, helps potential customers feel like they already know you.

Remember: for many people, your website is their first impression of your business. Make sure it reflects not only what you do, but who you are.

Local Businesses Have the Advantage

Here’s the best part: as a local business, you already have the community connection that large corporations can’t replicate. Show your face, share your story, and highlight your roots. People want to support their neighbors—they just need to see them.

The Takeaway

Your marketing doesn’t need to be perfect, but it does need to be personal. The more you show up as the human behind your business—both online and in person—the stronger your connection with your customers will be.

So, next time you hesitate to hit “post” on that selfie at your shop, remember: it might be the very thing that turns a follower into a loyal customer.

Ready to Put All the Pieces Together?

If you’re wondering how showing up personally fits into the bigger picture of your marketing, my new ebook The Marketing Puzzle for Local Small Businesses is for you. It breaks down all the essential pieces you need—social media, website, SEO, email, reviews, and more—and shows you how they all work together to attract and keep customers.

👉 [Download The Marketing Puzzle here] and start making your marketing work as hard as you do.

Comments +

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ready to learn more?

WE SHOULD TAKE THIS OFFLINE